Editor choice

The 3 Best Dog Chew Toys of 2023, Tested and Reviewed

We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation. Learn more.

Are you tired of constantly replacing your dog’s chew toys? Look no further than our comprehensive guide to finding the perfect dog chew toy. We purchased and tested 25 of the top-selling toys on the market, sending them out to volunteer testers to try with their pups in their homes. Our experts analyzed the toys’ durability, safety, and engagement level to help you make the best choice for your furry friend.

After months of testing and analysis, we found that the Kong Classic Dog Toy was the best overall choice for most dogs. Its durable rubber construction can withstand even the strongest chewers, and its hollow center can be filled with treats for extra engagement. However, we also found other great options for different needs and preferences.

Whether your dog is a power chewer or simply loves to play, our guide will help you find the perfect chew toy to keep them happy and entertained.

Our Top Pick

Best Overall: KONG – Classic Dog Toy, Durable Natural Rubber- Fun to Chew, Chase and Fetch – for Extra Small Dogs($7.99)
Jump to Review

Best Stretch:Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers Large Breed, Lifetime Replacement ($16.99)
Jump to Review

Best Durability:  WEST PAW Zogoflex Toppl Treat Dispensing Dog Toy Puzzle($19.95)
Jump to Review

Best Overall: KONG – Classic Dog Toy, Durable Natural Rubber- Fun to Chew, Chase and Fetch – for Extra Small Dogs($7.99)

AmazonNoApi Amazon.com
Last update was on: May 28, 2023 11:21 pm

  • can withstand heavy chewing, indestructible, long-lasting, chew-resistant, and withstands aggressive chewing.
  • can withstand power chewers, lasts for months, indestructible, durable, and safe.
  • keeps dogs busy and engaged, fun to play with, and keeps dogs occupied for hours or long periods of time.
  • great for stuffing with treats, peanut butter, or food, can be filled with treats and keeps dogs occupied, and excellent for training.
  • can be filled with treats or food, great for stuffing with treats.

  • some customers found the size too small or too big, smaller than expected, size was smaller than expected, very small for medium-sized dogs, too small for larger dogs, too small or too large, some customers
  • easily destroyed by aggressive chewers, easily destroyed by heavy chewers
  • hard to clean properly, difficult to clean
  • treats fall out too easily, does not dispense treats easily
  • product did not live up to its claim of being virtually indestructible, some dogs can still chew through it, easily destroyed by aggressive chewers

Best Stretch:Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers Large Breed, Lifetime Replacement ($16.99)

$16.99 $24.99
AmazonNoApi Amazon.com
Last update was on: May 28, 2023 11:21 pm

  • lasts longer than other toys, indestructible, holds up to constant chewing, survived aggressive chewer
  • keeps dogs occupied for hours, great for filling with treats, can be stuffed with treat
  • bounces in odd directions when thrown, keeps dogs busy trying to find the treat inside, dogs enjoy playing with it
  • smaller than expected, perfect size for large dogs
  • keeps dogs busy and entertained

  • not as indestructible as advertised, destroyed quickly, not as tough as claimed
  • did not last as long as expected for aggressive chewers
  • handle was chewed off easily, chewed off quickly
  • too small for larger dogs, heavy and not as big as expected
  • handle is a weak point

Best Durability:  WEST PAW Zogoflex Toppl Treat Dispensing Dog Toy Puzzle($19.95)

AmazonNoApi Amazon.com
Last update was on: May 28, 2023 11:21 pm

  • great for treat giving, stuffing with treats and food, dispensing treats in a fun way, keeping dogs entertained and challenged, holding a good amount of treats and kibble
  • sturdy and indestructible material, durable and can withstand moderate chewing, stands up to chewing and throwing, resilient and interesting food puzzle
  • dishwasher safe and easy to clean, wide opening, easier to clean than other similar products, easy to put food in and clean
  • many possible combinations for enrichment purposes, great for mental stimulation and training, provides enrichment and mental stimulation, dogs love eating kibble/treats out of it
  • perfect size for small/moderate/large dogs, large size holds enough food for a full meal

  • not suitable for heavy chewers, easily chewed and broken, not as durable as some other toys
  • expensive for some customers, considered expensive, too expensive for a single toy or requires purchasing multiple pieces
  • small size for the price, only comes in one size, too heavy for small dogs
  • treats fall out too easily, does not dispense treats easily
  • customers thought they were getting two pieces instead of one, need to purchase both separately

How We Tested

At XPANON, we take our product recommendations seriously. That’s why we tested 22 different products to determine which ones met our high standards for quality and performance.

To start, we carefully researched and selected a range of products that we believed represented the best options on the market. Then, we sent each product to a real home with a pet for real-world testing.

Our human testers followed the instructions provided to set up each product and took note of any difficulties encountered, tools required, and overall installation duration. Over the course of two weeks, they evaluated the products on ease of setup, ease of use, durability, and value. They also asked themselves if they would recommend the product they tested.

After gathering this first-hand information, we ranked and categorized our top picks. All of our recommendations received very high marks from our testers, giving you the confidence you need to make an informed purchase.

What to Look for

When shopping for dog chew toys, there are several factors to consider to ensure you select the right one for your furry friend.


Durability is a critical consideration when it comes to chew toys for dogs. You want to choose a toy that can withstand your pup’s strong jaws without breaking apart and becoming a choking hazard. Look for toys made of high-quality materials such as natural rubber, nylon, or Kevlar, which are known to be sturdy and long-lasting.

Size and Texture

The size and texture of the toy are also important considerations. Choose a toy that is the appropriate size for your dog’s breed and age, as well as one with a texture that appeals to their chewing habits. Some dogs prefer soft and squishy toys, while others prefer hard and textured ones. You may need to experiment with different options to find the right fit for your pup.


Consider the intended purpose of the chew toy. Is it designed for teething puppies, or for adult dogs to chew on for dental health? Some toys are specifically made to help clean teeth and massage gums, while others are meant to provide mental stimulation and satisfy a dog’s natural urge to chew.


Always prioritize safety when selecting a chew toy for your dog. Avoid toys with small parts that can break off and become a choking hazard, and steer clear of toys that are made with toxic materials. Additionally, supervise your dog when they are playing with their toy to ensure they don’t accidentally ingest any parts.

Why Trust Xpanon

Our team at Xpanon is dedicated to providing pet owners with the best product recommendations for their furry friends. Our dog chew toy roundup was written by a team of experienced writers and dog owners who have personally tested each toy to ensure their durability, safety, and functionality. You can trust our recommendations to help you find the perfect chew toy for your pup.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Compare items
  • Total (0)